Reviews for The Island Creamery

10/29/2024 - Magaly C.
The Island Creamery offers a wide variety of ice cream flavors that can make decision-making challenging. The Ice Cream Sundae (Reese's) was so big, it felt like a sweet indulgence that could give anyone a sugar rush. The prices are reasonable, and the staff was quick to serve us, making it a convenient stop for a refreshing treat on a hot day.

06/01/2024 - B A.
so good

05/16/2021 - Karye
I highly recommend NEVER coming here. I almost never write bad reviews because everyone has bad days. But I wish I would have come on here to read reviews before going here because they were all spot on. You'd think being in a busy tourist attraction, you'd have better staff, service, and product! The ice cream was really hard and nothing special. The staff never talked to ANYONE in there and seemed to have a hard time understanding anything anyone was saying. They rolled their eyes a lot and moved very slowly, despite the line of customers waiting. I would never EVER come back here, even if I was paid to. Their customers should be the ones getting paid because the prices and lack of good product are shameful. One of the worst experiences I've ever had in the service industry.