Reviews for Nicola's Italian Restaurant

07/23/2025 - Kb C.
I've got a "try everything twice" philosophy, and revisiting Nicola's confirmed it's worth every bite-especially the tortellini formaggio with prosciutto, which was absolutely incredible. The creamy pesto fettuccine my boyfriend had made me seriously consider stealing a fork or two, and the raspberry cheesecake dessert left us practically rolling out the door. With friendly service, fresh flavors, and a cozy vibe that's perfect for dining al fresco in warmer months, this cozy Italian joint made a memorable impression that's hard to forget.

03/04/2009 - MenuPix User
Amazing and romantic. The food and service is always top notch! It is a very small place that makes you feel cozy and warm. The owners are a very sweet couple who are always there, making sure people feel special. We love going there and the prices are reasonable enough for us to go often.