Reviews for Casino Bar

11/26/2024 - Michael C.
This bar is awesome. The staff are all super friendly, attentive, and good at what they do. Special shoutout to bartender Nikolei, he's the best. The only thing that does suck is the $50 card minimum, but there is an atm at the bar anyways. When its a slow day, its a chill bar. When its a busy day, this place gets jumping with a DJ and everything. My friends and I are semi-regulars in the summer because of our boat, and there's never been a bad time here. Beautiful view too. Came over here after hanging on the beach with my friends, fun atmosphere and live music with a view of the water! So much fun. The bar is hopping with great music and memorable entertainment. The bar help is awesome and the atmosphere is electric. We took our boat over to Davis Park for lunch and happen to go into the Casino Bar and Grill. It was kid friendly, people were friendly and the food was delicious. I ordered a cold Lobster Roll and my husband got an Ahi Tuna wrap. I don't like my lobster rolls with too much mayo and this one was just that. I didn't get a chance to ask my husband how his wrap was because it was already gone. They had corn hole for the kids to play with and after lunch we walked right down to the ocean. Great location, great bartenders, great servers, amazing food! This is the only restaurant at Davis Park, Fire Island, but there is no need for another one. Once you are done with dinner on the restaurant side, make sure to pop over to the party side for some after-dinner festivities! Great atmosphere. Monday karaoke, Tuesday bingo, Wednesday trivia. Wednesday DJ and dancing This place f-ck-ng rules and if you don't think so you have a huge dump in your pants. We were just there Saturday July 8,2017. Pretty busy at night for a beach bar. The crowed is very diversified in age,from young to older.The rocket fuels are the best there,little pricey but good. We also had some food from the snack bar and must say not bad at all. Bartenders very quick with getting a drink and nice. The music was awesome and the dance floor was packed most of the night. The DJ was playing music for every age group which i personally liked as me and my girl are not old but don't want to hear hip hop or techno music all night at a beach bar.and also saw that as the night went on and the crowed got younger the DJ changed the music up. I think his name is Glen. There were some songs I didn't like but the dance floor was still full and I realize a person is not going to like everything that is played. First time at night for me as we normally come on a Sunday with the bands. Kevin, Nate and Frank are all I need in my life. Also... What's Nate's number? Love from the people that drank you out of cider. So impressed with the Casino this season! Went over to Davis on the boat for an impulse decision to eat here on a Thursday evening. Very glad we did because everything that we ordered was absolutely delicious. We had a flat iron steak special, flounder special, bacon wrapped monkfish, and the whalebone farfalle. I had the farfalle, it was a huge portion with a bountiful amount of shrimp and asparagus. The sauce was so tasty too! We also had the shrimp & avocado appetizer - the shrimp was so fresh and cooked to perfection...also loved the sauce with that. We sat outside, watched a beautiful sunset and enjoy our tasty drinks and meals. Anxious to go back! The seared tuna special was much better than I was expecting given the lack of competition. Kids meals were good. Service was slow, unprofessional, and sometimes absentee. Served a $7 beer and had to ask for a glass. Had to ask for bread. Kitchen slow to get food out. Stupid and confusing policy about no tips on credit cards, and then a gratuity was charged to my card - check your bill carefully. First of all, I'm not sure why this restaurant is under the category of "casinos", since it is not a gambling establishment. With that being said, the Casino Cafe is one of my favorite restaurants which I try to visit at least once every year. It is only one of two oceanfront restaurants on all of Fire Island, and the only restaurant in Davis Park. Therefore, with the spectacular view and captive market, the food could be mediocre and the place would still probably be packed! Fortunately, that is not the case as the restaurant consistently produces high quality food with excellent service. The items on the standard menu are excellent in their own right, however, there is a list of nightly specials that are always fresh and creative. The Oysters Rockefeller is my all time favorite appetizer. I have tried this dish at various restaurants throughout the East coast and have never been able to find one that compares. I have never been disappointed with fresh fish selections and scallops. Whether chosen as an entree or appetizer they are always cooked to perfection and never disappoint. As a gluten free diner, I was pleased to see some gluten free options on the menu. However, the servers are always happy to check with the chef to see if any of the other dishes can be modified, and the chef is always happy to oblige if it is possible. When the weather is good, outdoor seating on the deck is highly recommended. There is no better way to enjoy a meal than with the sound of waves gently crashing in the background. If weather doesn't permit, eating in the ocean view dining room is recommended during daylight hours. However, the bay view dining room is perfect for watching the sunset and gazing at the lights on and across the bay as night falls. The restaurant bar area is always hopping with a slightly older crowd and the bartenders are extremely friendly and competent. The Casino Bar is right next door and draws a somewhat younger crowd. Various entertainment events such as live bands, DJ, karaoke and trivia are scheduled. During the day it's a great place to walk up from the beach to grab a refreshing cocktail, sit back, and enjoy this special place in paradise.