Reviews for Pickaway Pickins

05/25/2025 - Erica H.
During a short trip through West Virginia, I enjoyed a delicious vegetable beef soup with tender beef and fresh vegetables, along with a fresh salad bar and homemade sandwiches that felt like a warm, home-cooked meal. The homemade pies were unforgettable-especially the Key Lime-and the friendly service and cozy atmosphere made the whole experience truly special.

03/19/2025 - Wolf L.
During a recent trip to West Virginia, I discovered a diner that serves the most incredible pie I've ever tasted. The lunch buffet featured a variety of delicious homemade dishes, including a standout vegetable beef soup that I'm still craving. With exceptional service and a welcoming atmosphere, it felt like dining at a friend's house, making it a memorable experience overall.

07/13/2024 - Stella T.
great food

05/11/2023 - Teresa
I've the ribs and steaks

02/21/2023 - MenuPix User
I wouldn't recommend going here....you pay at the register,without looking over what you ordered and prices....when you ask to go over your bill....they get offensive...way overpriced for what you get....you can go to Applebee's get a 3 coarse meal CHEAPER and friendlier SERVICE!!