Reviews for Oscar's Italian Restaurant

04/15/2024 - MenuPix User

03/18/2024 - MenuPix User

01/13/2024 - MenuPix User

12/30/2023 - MenuPix User

12/13/2020 - JR
I wish I could give this place negative stars. Oscar is more brain dead than Terry Schiavo, his staff are as rude as a wild pack of maskless Karens wanting to speak to a manager despite clear signs stating "no mask no entry", and his kitchen couldn't get an order right if their children were held at gunpoint and they had the cookbook equivalent of hooked-on-phonics instructing them how to make the meals. I've seen third world soup kitchens run better than this. Oscar is the pizzeria-version of Bernie Madoff with the amount of fraud his "restaurant" has pulled off on completely butchering his customers' orders. Even AFTER they've been read back to you on the phone multiple times to make sure the glorified paperweight on the other end gets it right (which I'm not entirely sure isn't just a trained parrot instructed just to repeat what you said back to you so they can throw whatever crap in the oven and serve it to you with a scat-eating grin). The incompetence was there LONG before the pandemic, and despite giving them multiple chances and constructive criticism in the past, the cycle continues. The food itself has also gotten worse lately, which was the only thing that kept me going back at that point. If you've ever heard the phrase "you're not pretty enough to be this stupid" just replace it with "your food isn't delicious enough for your service to be this inept, subpar, and obnoxious." I envy the people that have never heard of Oscar's. They're bush-league pizza at this point and it's Yorktown's biggest embarrassment.