Reviews for Number One Pizza

04/27/2025 - Shannon A.
While staying at a nearby hotel, I decided to grab pizza from this charming spot and was pleasantly surprised by the generous portions and friendly staff. The New York-style pizza was delicious, with a crispy crust and flavorful sauce, making it a place I'll definitely return to.

01/02/2025 - Rebel L.
I stayed at the hotel nearby and didn't want to travel far for food, so I found this amazing pizza place with delicious food and generous portions. The owners and staff were incredibly friendly, making the experience even better. I can't wait to go back and enjoy more of their tasty pizza and welcoming atmosphere.

04/20/2024 - Silver C.
Enchanting

08/15/2023 - Betsy
I love the intricate deep flavor of the sauces! I also love Josie!!

06/01/2023 - Cheryl
Love Love their pizza. After all the years coming to the Lake, finally found this GEM.

08/22/2022 - MenuPix User
Great people working there, great pizza!

06/02/2022 - MenuPix User
With the exception of one other in Walden, New York, this is the best pizza I have had in eighty five years. They are on a par. Married to an Italian we ate plenty of them.

05/08/2022 - Flat Rock
Best Sicilian in Lake George

05/23/2021 - Frank
Pizza was really good. Hot subbs are lousy. Don't bother going when they are an hour or less from closing. The lady is mean, rude and miserable and charges you whatever she feels like I guess! It's a shame because they do have good pizza.