Reviews for Rockaway Pizzeria

04/03/2023 - MenuPix User
Told it would be 40 minutes to pick up and after waiting for 2 hours it finally came out.

Owner in the back cursing and miserable.

Instead of being happy for customers he is miserable that he is busy.

Never again!

11/08/2021 - Stefan S.
Simply the best in the area.

07/12/2021 - Jonny D.
Simply the best

06/28/2021 - Gini
I feel like I am in the Big Apple. every time I eat a pizza

05/30/2021 - Daniel W.
Literally the best pizza outside of the NYC metro area

03/19/2021 - Jonny Kieska
Only place we order from now!!!

02/24/2021 - Buddy V.
They use the little crispy cupping pepperoni and also have great Italian sub

02/17/2021 - Alaina
Delicious New York style!

02/12/2021 - Kayla
Delicious pizza and garlic knots!

02/10/2021 - Paul H.
I’m from Queens, recently moved to Pittsburgh, and have not liked any of the pizza I’ve tried... until now. Great, thin crispy crust, the right amount of cheese and a great sauce make this an authentic NY pizza experience. Highly recommend!

02/08/2021 - Harry
Grandma pie with sesame seeds is killer

01/15/2021 - Allison
Amazing white pizza!

01/13/2021 - Jack
Awesome pizza, cooked well done. Some people think that’s burnt I guess, but for me, I like it crispy! Wait times can be long, but they seem to be busy as hell at all times. Couldn’t recommend more for great NY style pizza packed with tons flavor!

01/04/2021 - Disappointed
Everything was burned and salty. So much salt. NY pizza doesn't fold it cracks. So many employees milling around doing nothing. 1.5 hrs for pickup order. Still sat in restaurant waiting for 20 minutes for food to be ready. There are other way better local pizzerias in south western PA. Disappointed. Don't fall for the "buzz" around this place like I did.

01/03/2021 - Todd
Ordered tonight for the first time and we ordered 3 pizzas the pizza was good and the portion sizes of the slices was excellent only complaint I have was the crust was kinda hard

06/06/2018 - Bob F
Grewup eating Fioris and Mineos,in my opinion this pizza is as good.

06/06/2018 - Bob F
Grewup eating Fioris and Mineos,in my opinion this pizza is as good.