Reviews for Nicky D's Coney Island

08/16/2025 - Leslie V.
Anton provided excellent service by getting my order right on the first try and anticipating exactly what I wanted. The food, including the grilled chicken sandwich, patty melt, Greek salad, and chili dogs, was consistently fresh and delicious, with a clean and spotless environment enhancing the overall experience. Despite occasional wait times due to fresh preparation, the friendly staff and attentive owner make this a reliable choice that I'm happy to return to regularly.

09/15/2024 - Asia G.
Anton was incredibly efficient, getting my order perfect on the first try without any need for clarification. The food at Nicky D's is hands down the best in the entire neighborhood, with exceptional service and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps me coming back for more.