Reviews for Athens Pizza of Jaffrey

03/17/2025 - Kerry M.
The pizza at this establishment is exceptional, with a perfect balance of crispy crust and gooey cheese that keeps me coming back for more. I appreciate the friendly service and the attention to detail in preparing my orders just the way I like them. Whether I'm enjoying a meal in or picking up lunch, I always leave satisfied and excited for my next visit.

06/23/2024 - Pete P.
Always good!

05/18/2024 - MenuPix User
I got a BLT grinder there today and it was the worst one that I have ever had there. Bacon wasn't cooked, almost on the raw side, it was disgustingly gross. Roll wasn't even toasted, which they always are, I could'nt even get through the first half of it and tossed it in the trash. I have been getting grinders and pizza there for years, in fact, since they've opened in Jaffrey and before that I went to the one in Keene. If I had been eating there I would have returned it to the counter but was all the way back at home. Not sure if they have new owners or what, but for $15 a pop I won't be ordering another for sure. What a shame to not have more pride in the product that you make for the public consumer. Shame on you.

06/03/2023 - Phyl
What are the prices, where is the menu; okay food but not upfront asked for itemized bill. They don't have one???

09/10/2021 - Jacob
They are very rude. The pizza is great, everything else is awful

04/07/2021 - Paul Ferrell
this place is the best. Great food. Friendly service! You would have to be a bitter person to disagree

07/10/2020 - Jaffrey
Great pizza and I recently started buying their chef salads and they are amazing! Best chef salad I've had. Well priced items, though I do wish their menu was available online.

06/18/2018 - MenuPix User
Owner very rude forgot have our order
The punter needs to be pleasant more and smile

09/12/2017 - Pete
Love the grinders an salads there just one problem guy has to get a personality seems like it's a chore to take your order an say thank you

01/04/2014 - john
what kind of restaurant doesnt have a menu posted online.....only low rate cheap places like this