Reviews for Taste Of Italy Pizzeria

06/11/2024 - Joshua T.
Growing up, my family was all about this place we just moved back to the Vineland/Millville area a few weeks ago and we visited there the first week! In Georgia, we had Domino's but nothing could compare to Taste of Italy. The prices might be a little high, but the food is totally worth it - two cheese pizzas set us back $25. I can't wait to try something new next time and update my review, but for now, I'm just grateful for their delicious food and accommodating service - even if credit card orders and delivery come with a small extra cost. Thanks for the tasty meals!

09/08/2012 - Pam L.
Taste of Italy, Main Road, Vineland has lost a customer. Eric and I both had a rough day. I don’t have a lot of money, but I thought we both deserved a treat. So I looked up their Facebook page (which includes photos of their menu with prices). Their daily specials were updated until Wednesday. Not having much cash, I ordered what I could afford, carefully calculating the prices listed and tax and tip for the delivery guy. Our order arrived 40 minutes later with a different price than what I’d figured. That difference was $12. Now $12 might not be lot of money to most folks, but to me it’s a lot. The delivery guy called the restaurant and eventually put me on the phone with the girl on the other end. She translated for the owner who I could hear talking in the background. Apparently those prices are old prices, there would be no compromise…even though the false advertising was their problem. Honestly, if they had met me half way, I would have paid $6 if they ate $6. Instead, they stood firm and I sent the food back. I won’t be ordering from them again. I didn’t post their menu, they did. I later looked up their info on other sites and found the same menu with the same pricing. After posting on Facebook of my dissatisfaction, several other folks messaged me that they had had the same problem there, as well as over-charging, and different prices on the same order. Their food is pretty good for a small local business, but it’s a shame they don’t seem to know anything about advertising or customer service. P.S. The delivery guy was very nice, and I actually gave him a small tip just for coming out and for attempting to mediate. I hope they don’t subject him to less polite disgruntled customers.