Reviews for Black River General Store

02/03/2025 - Aisha L.
The general store in Pottersville serves excellent breakfast and lunch options, including customizable sandwiches and delicious homemade soups. The friendly staff and quick service make it a great choice for a meal, and their freshly baked goods and desserts, particularly the carrot cake, are outstanding.

08/17/2020 - Suzan
Loved the cookies!
great variety of snacks and meals!

05/19/2011 - Tim
I'm a regular and sucker for their muffin's! Great home cooked food and was glad to see the addition of cheese steaks and hamburgers (organic), both excellent. Need to forget about your diet though and top it off with one of their chocolate chip cookies! Mmm, Mmmm!

09/23/2010 - Dee
This morning I had the pleasure of finding this great little place just down the road from my new job. I have been looking for a spot for breakfast and lunch and happened upon it today...it was quite a treat to find an actual DELI after moving back to NJ from PA. I will be back!

06/20/2009 - Blake,,, Far Hills NJ
It is such a pleasure to see that people actually make their own recipes and food unlike all the other deli's that but buy pre made garbage , taste the difference it is well worth the price YOU GET WHAT YOU PAY FOR!!!!

06/20/2009 - Sam, Gladstone, NJ
I was absolutely amazed this is the cleanest, nicest and most superb food offerings available you could eat off the floors it is so clean in there, the people could not be any nicer way to go Chef Davis