Reviews for Bayshore Restaurant

5 stars |
![]() |
|
4 votes - | 17% |
4 stars |
![]() |
|
9 votes - | 39% |
3 stars |
![]() |
|
3 votes - | 13% |
2 stars |
![]() |
|
3 votes - | 13% |
1 star |
![]() |
|
4 votes - | 17% |
Latest MenuPix Reviews
02/16/2025 - Little M.
The Stromboli with Ricotta cheese is simply fantastic, and the NY strip steak was cooked to perfection. Despite its unassuming exterior, the food and service at Bayshore are exceptional, making it a must-visit destination for anyone craving delicious Italian cuisine.
09/03/2024 - MenuPix User
Ordered 3 large cheesesteaks for delivery we are located less than one mile from restaurant. Delivery took two and a half hours the sandwiches were on a load of stale toasted French bread cot all the way open with very little overcooked stead and under cooked onions. I have never had a sandwich that was worse than their cheesesteaks. Food is expensive and when you order from a restaurant it should be good. We will never go there again and will tell everyone in the campground our experience with your establishment
05/14/2024 - Marcela V.
Good Food
08/16/2022 - Len
Has been a disappointment this year. (July 2022) Found Pizzas wet & soggy on bottom with oil & grease.
Poured oil from the top of cheese. Will be trying another pizza shop in my Aug stay.
02/27/2013 - BILLY P.
I have no idea how the food is simply because as I walked in,A HUGE rat ran through the dining area. I asked to see the manager, who was a very unkempt looking guy named John who told me I was crazy & if I did not like it, pardon my quote,"GET THE F**K OUTTA HERE" Which we did. We went to another place in SEA-ISLE CITY & the owner told me that they had heard a lot of ROACH complaints about the same place... I think their name was gulianno or something like that, but their food was great .
05/11/2012 - Sam P.
I heard their soup is made fresh daily!!!! You can't get that anywhere else. The Gem isn't all that. Either is Papi Lugi.
10/04/2010 - Shirley C.
! star, because that was the lowest I could give it.
Don't waste your time, the food was decent, but waaaaaaayyyyyy overpriced, and I had to wait 2 HOURS for delivery. When I called to complain, I was told to "pick it up next time". Well, there will not be a next time.