Reviews for New World Pizza & Cafe

01/06/2025 - Sean R.
The pizza at New World is our favorite in the area, with a thin crust that is perfectly crispy. Their wings are decent, though I wish they were a bit crispier, but the Buffalo sauce is very good. The caprese salad is also delicious, loaded with thick cut tomatoes and tons of basil. The prices can get a bit high with additional toppings, but the quality is worth it. Delivery is reliable, typically arriving within 45-60 minutes. Overall, New World Pizza is a great option for delicious and fresh pizza.

02/18/2020 - BoroPizzaHunter
I love New World Pizza. They have so many great pizza and sandwich options. Their sauce stands above most other pizzeria's I've been to. The staff is always very friendly and service is quick. The pepperoni roll was my favorite back when I was eating meat. Now, as a vegetarian, I find myself enjoying the red pepper and tomato slice and the Margherita slices. They also do authentic zeppole that you simply must try!

02/18/2020 - Cole R.
I was hiking in the Sourland Mountain Preserve down the road a little ways and after the hike I was craving some carbs. New World was a solid choice. The pizza tastes great. The first slice was so good I had to order another one!