Reviews for Stephanie's Italian Restaurant

09/02/2024 - Paul M.
We discovered Stephanie's after noticing her sign at Fat Fish and decided to check it out after seeing it twice. After looking up reviews and the menu online, we were pleasantly surprised by the cozy yet elegant atmosphere and the delicious food at Stephanie's. The personalized service, fantastic dishes, and warm ambiance made our dining experience truly memorable and enjoyable.

07/11/2024 - M F.
very good food

02/25/2021 - AL
Awesome food! Should say something, when I tell you I have been eating at Stephanie's for over 15 years. And these last few months with covid...I have been placing take out orders... and they walk it right out to my car! And, they put up ultra violet lighting so that it kills germs! What more could you ask for!
Xoxo

08/12/2015 - marlene kostka
This was our second dinner visit after being encouraged by a business associate that Stephanie's was the best restaurant on the Caldwell strip. He is right. The restaurant is immaculate as are the rest rooms. It is wise to make reservations for warm weather patio seating or indoors. Customers with 2 in the party are comfortably seated at tables for four. John our waiter is pleasant friendly and efficient. He knows his specials and menu backwards and forwards. Two hostesses keep atmosphere neat and pleasant. Tap or bottled water is offered. The bread is top quality: warm, crusty and fresh, served with butter or oil/balsamic dressing. Fresh ground pepper mills seat each table. Windows to the street are clean and pleasant for late afternoon dining to view the park across the street and the flower pots decorating the outside. PArking is plentiful w/ no meters as entrance is in the rear. The menu offers fresh seafood and shellfish, varietal salads and appetizers, pork and veal are tender and expertly prepared and appealing to the eye when plated. Atmeal's end a platter of fresh grapes is offered gratis. It is a bring your own wine or beer....no set up fees or corking charges. The business exudes conscientiousness, efficiency and care.I t is a favorite spot.