Reviews for Stefano's Pizzeria

05/01/2024 - Im T.
Nifty

10/31/2015 - joseph finnegan
The worst pace order two dinners the waiter insited that they come with sales told him they don't at end of the meal they charged us for the salads then I addressed the waiter he said I will take care of it then the owner comes over and says we must pay mean while plastic surgery on the tv never again

12/03/2013 - jz
have been going to stefano for years,it is always delicious and very polite service and spotless pizzeria.

10/14/2012 - Dave
I grabbed 2 slices of regular pizza, no toppings, no drink

gave the guy a 20, I got back a 10, a 1, and a couple coins

I think the owner takes whatever he can get away with

I was working and had no time or energy to fight for my food...I just wanted a quick lunch

06/01/2011 - Joan Valenti
DO NOT, I repeat, Do not eat here! They verbally abuse their employees and then refuse to pay them the right amount!!! Try DaVince in Wayne or Aldos in Wayne if you want to stay in the area. Opa is also a nice alternative!

Oh and by the way, the owners are not even Italian, what the hell do they know about Italian food?!

12/27/2010 - Anthony
The food is good, but they forgot my salad, the pizza is not good, don't ever ask for fresh mozarella, they will put very little dot of cheese in each slice, and price is almost $19 dollars, really ridiculous overpriced, I stoped going there, after I gave them many chances, people is nice, just about it.

10/22/2010 - Gen
We've been going to Stefanos since they opened their doors about 12 years ago and keep going back because of the wonderful food! You might have to wait 90 minutes for food to be delivered because they have so many deliveries to make because they are JUST THAT GOOD! Dinners are phenomenal! Especially the Penne w/Vodka Sauce and the Chicken Parmigiana! Once you try their food, you'll be back for more. Guaranteed!!!! They could be a little friendlier, but the food is what matters to me. As a result of their great food, they just opened a fancy restaurant adjacent to their pizzeria! Try it!

06/06/2010 - pam
although the food was decent the service was terrible. The attitude of the owner chef was appalling. we sat for 1 hour and 20 minutes and all we had was salad. no wine glasses for 45 minutes. was not offered dessert or any other course. worst place I've been to in a long time. for a new place they are not doing much to establish a good reputation and encourage repeat customers. we live locally and would not go again or encourage others to visit.