Reviews for Brooklyn Bagels & Deli

05/29/2025 - Mandy D.
The bagels here are large, flavorful, and generously spread with cream cheese, making them a great value. The staff are genuinely friendly and create a welcoming atmosphere, often engaging with customers and fostering a sense of community. Although bagels can sell out quickly around noon, arriving earlier ensures a fresh selection, and the variety of pastries, sandwiches, and drinks adds to the overall experience.

07/18/2024 - Anthony F.
Tried this deli after my usual spot closed, and it turned out to be a solid choice for bagels. The bagels are generous in size, loaded with cream cheese, and reasonably priced. The staff is friendly, the seating area outside is charming, and they offer a variety of pastries, sandwiches, and drinks.

04/21/2012 - freehold local
I've been coming to Brooklyn bagels since i was 12.
nine years later i still think this is the best bagel shop probably in the state. bagels are made to perfection NY style. great sandwiches, and prices are very reasonable. two thumbs up. keep doing what you guys are doing.

08/10/2011 - Freehold Resident
Bagels keep going up in price and down in size and quality...sorry Lou

07/13/2011 - Kenny from the VFW
Slow service seems to have his favorites

10/05/2010 - sayonna doster
Great breakfast/lunch spot!The selection of bagels,and rolls compliment any variety of the daily made salads,creamcheese spreads or fresh deli meats&cheeses.The chicken salad on practically any bagel,roll or bread is a must try!The only complaints I have are 1.there is no menu posted on the web-site and2.the chocolate bagels are so good,I almost bit my finger eating one...true story!

02/22/2009 - JOE
BEST HOT BAGELS PERIOD.
EXTINSIVE BOARS HEAD BRAND, GREAT PRICES.