Reviews for Georgie's Diner

02/19/2024 - MenuPix User

01/08/2024 - MenuPix User

11/06/2022 - Jorge N
Up front I want to say that the waitresses were AMAZING and this review in no way should reflect on them trying to make the best of this situation. This without a doubt in my mind falls squarely on back of house and management.

Summary: Kitchen sent out a sandwich that had very little meat, refused to fix, then refused to make a new plate, while being rude enough to the waitress that she was crying while apologizing, despite the fact that she did nothing wrong.

I waited a full day to post the review to give myself time to calm down and make sure I didn't write something in the heat of the moment.

I ordered a Philly Cheese Steak and my wife ordered the Gyro. I took a bite of my sandwich and surprised I got nothing but onion and pepper I opened it up to look at it. I was surprised to find almost no meat in it, but figured that mistakes happened. When the waitress came around to our table I showed her the sandwich which she immediately agreed looked light on meat and took back to the kitchen.

After a few minutes she came back and notified us that the cook said that was the correct portion amount and he would not add more meat to the sandwich (keep in mind the gyro my wife was enjoying had at least three times the amount of meat). The waitress offered to cancel that out and have me order another item at which point I attempted to order the bacon burger.

I say attempted to order the burger because again in a few minutes the waitress came out, clearly upset, and stated that the cook not only would not add meat to the sandwich, but flat out refused to make a different meal for our table. She offered to comp the table and apologized which was upsetting because she did absolutely nothing wrong.

My family finished the fries on my plate and left, making sure to tip the waitress who was so helpful and had to deal with the cook. At no point did we ask for anything to be comped, and actually would have still been happy to pay for the gyro and burger if they had been made. My wife and I were simply in shock at the rudeness of the cook, and the management not stepping in to address the issue when their waitstaff was trying to help a situation they had no responsibility for.

11/16/2020 - Dave & Cindy Cook
Great food, family run business, great fast service.
Owner is very personable and makes you feel at home there. Always greets all his customers and makes sure you have everything you need. We make a point of eating there everytime we are in town.
Indoor and outdoor patio seating. Music on patio on weekends. Love it. Best Gyros ever.