Reviews for Paisano's Italian Restaurant

05/19/2023 - MenuPix User
We've been going here since it first opened and the front door was on the other side of the building. Tonight was dismal. Mushroom appetizer was sent back. It was the consistency of a burned flip flop covered in ketchup. The other dishes were NOT like the old days. Sausage lentil soup is not the same - watery and bland. 1/2 order main dishes were equally disappointing. Scallops were grainy. For $100 w/tip, it was not the experience we were expecting.

06/25/2022 - LJ
I am an Italian who grew up on “real Italian food.” My grandmother (who immigrated from Italy through Ellis island ) made her own pasta, bread, cheese, cookies, tomato paste, tomato gravy and everything in between. Also being a New Yorker I am a connoisseur of fine Italian food.
Paisano’s is the closest I’ve come to true Italian food/flavor in over a decade. The flavor and taste of the linguine with clam sauce was truly heavenly. Can’t wait to try again!

04/19/2022 - MenuPix User
Had a wonderful experience at this lovely restaurant a few weeks ago. Outstanding food and excellent service. Terrific ambiance! Will definitely be returning!!

08/16/2016 - Unknown
Horrible place bad service and food was cold staff very unfriendly will not return.

03/01/2014 - Meg F
On the pricey side but it was very well worth it. Food was just sooo delicious! Atmosphere is elegant and perfect for a date. I wouldn't bring children here since it seems to cater to a quiet, romantic atmosphere. Will definitely be back!