Reviews for Pine Island Pizza

04/05/2024 - MenuPix User

02/05/2024 - MenuPix User

01/07/2024 - MenuPix User

05/21/2022 - Adrianna
Great pizza and great family

04/19/2022 - MenuPix User
Burnt pizza taste like a cracker with tomato sauce and cheese was old. Nothing like NY style!

Owner should not try to steer and remember customer is always right! Don’t engage in a long drawn out argument pretending to be someone else. Your husband makes the best pizza, you shouldn’t be defending someone who doesn’t know how to make pizza’s. New hire? I’ve been going there since you opened but, the quality has gone way down. Don’t lose your business to some new hire who neither regards constructive criticism and belittles his customers for giving their opinion. Save your business! Do yourself and your husband a big favor fire the guy!

03/04/2022 - Local customer
Top drawer pizza. No comparison to other pizza providers!! Great sauce, thin crust and very tasty. The antipasto salad is wonderful with pity of goodies even anchovies if you’re game. If you want to be warmly greeted and have a terrific lunch or dinner, order in or take out this is the place to go.

05/08/2020 - MenuPix User
Top Shelf Pizza this is the best why go anywhere else take it from and old Italian this is great pizza and Pete Steve and Melissa they are the best