Reviews for Monticello Bagel Bakery

10/06/2024 - Vi B.
The bagel bakery in Monticello is a well-established local favorite, known for its delicious array of bagels and mouthwatering sandwiches. Despite the occasional line inside, the friendly staff works diligently to ensure orders are taken and prepared efficiently, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere for patrons to enjoy their meal.

06/03/2024 - Gail M.
AWESOME!

08/07/2021 - MenuPix User
SERVICE DEPARTMENT AT ROBERT GREEN CHEVROLET LOVES THE SERVICE AND BAGEL SANDWICHES. WE GO ORDER FROM THERE EVERY SATURDAY MORNING FOR DELIVERY AND THE DELIVERY ALWAYS ARRIVES WITH HOT FOOD AND A SMILE. WE TRULY APPRECIATE YOU GUYS!!!!

07/12/2020 - MenuPix User
Poor service with bad attitude. Bagels are at best average - store would not survive in NYC or Long Island. Overpriced. Dirty and poor food handling

11/07/2018 - Peg McCormick
Live in NC now, miss my NY Family and Monticello Bagels!

01/12/2014 - Carlos Danger
The everything bagel with cream cheese I had gets an A+

The fact that the shop owner prepares food without gloves, and then handles everyone's money is a real turn-off and gross. It's worth a D- at best.

Just do the right thing...Have certain people handle money and NOT prepare or touch the food, and another person only prepare and handle the food!

Duh!