Reviews for Rymolene's Pies

05/03/2024 - Jeri W.
Always delicious!

11/23/2023 - MenuPix User

08/14/2023 - Judy
Delicious And unusual! Icebox as well as regular pies. I got two icebox pies the last time because it was so hot outside. Delicious!

06/18/2023 - MenuPix User
If this review was just for the pie, I'd give it five stars. The coconut cream is exceptional, and I highly recommend the smores pie. (The brown sugar is just okay.)
The problem is that they opened a second location on College Ave. and are highly inconsistent with when they're there. I've been by multiple times during business hours only to find they're closed up. They recently changed the hours at the second location to weekends only, so I hoped that would rectify the situation. Tried again a couple of days ago during their new hours (3 hours before close), and again, no one was there.
If there's something going on and the shop will be closed, it's good business practice to let people know. In the meantime, I'm done trying. The pie isn't good enough for me to drive across town to their other location just for that, and since I'm never over there, I just won't be a customer anymore.

09/18/2021 - JackieB
Friendly staff Great Pies Keylime our favorite!! ❤

02/08/2021 - Leslie
Best pies ever! Great selection but our favorite is the coconut creme!

04/12/2020 - MenuPix User
Best pies I have ever tasted. Better than Rick's Bakery