Reviews for Sayville Athletic Club

08/03/2025 - Daniel B.
The restaurant offers a diverse menu with a variety of flavorful dishes. The service was attentive and friendly throughout the meal. The atmosphere is comfortable, making it suitable for both casual dining and special occasions.

07/08/2024 - Kelly F.
i love it!!!

11/22/2020 - Fred the human iPod
A tantalizing experience worthy of a revisit i strongly recommend the American classic Reuben sandwich . It's a playful dish with the right balance of fries and pastrami. The seasoning on the pastrami is glorious. Ur tastebuds will be playful yet frisky while biting into this spry sandwich's. The bread is fresh and the flavor boasts a bold yet refined style as seen in a perfected Reuben sandwich.

11/22/2020 - Fred the human iPod
The Reuben ceaser salad is a original creation that's upgrades the chicken ceaser salad to a ceaser salad with pastrami. It's like and frisky and not afraid to show a little boldness with the smoked pastrami flavor. The dressing is well balanced and there wasn't too much tossed in where it makes the salad limp. It was crunchy and refined w a well balanced dressing flavor. The meat was 6 star quality I could put six stars down however so I am giving it a full five stars unless the review site tries to change my stars again.

04/25/2020 - MenuPix User
Great place and great food. A fun evening out with friends, Plan to take-out during this time and go back when normal life returns:))