Reviews for Anthony's Pizza & Pasta
| 5 stars |
|
|
5 votes - | 33% |
| 4 stars |
|
|
10 votes - | 67% |
| 3 stars |
|
|
0 votes - | 0% |
| 2 stars |
|
|
0 votes - | 0% |
| 1 star |
|
|
0 votes - | 0% |
Latest MenuPix Reviews
08/11/2025 - Ej S.
Anthony's Pizza and Pasta offers authentic, delicious New York-style pizza with fresh dough, homemade sauce, and high-quality cheese, accompanied by friendly and efficient service. Whether grabbing a slice, ordering a specialty pie, or catering an event, the consistently great flavors, reasonable prices, and community-focused atmosphere make it a favorite for me and my family.
03/15/2025 - Amy V.
Anthony's Pizza and Pasta in West Islip offers a fantastic selection of authentic pizzas and Italian entrí©es, making it a favorite among locals. The friendly staff and community-oriented atmosphere, combined with delicious food, ensure a satisfying dining experience every time.
06/24/2024 - Melvin S.
Great food!
10/21/2009 - JOHN C
DEFINITELY A SLEEPER SMALL PLACE EXCELLENT
FOOD ESPECIALLY THEIR CATERING