Reviews for Athena Greek Restaurant

07/04/2025 - Philly M.
Athena Greek Restaurant in Amityville has completely won me over with its authentic flavors, especially the spanakopita and chicken in orange ginger sauce that keep me coming back weekly. The friendly staff, cozy atmosphere, and consistently amazing dishes-from lamb-loaded gyros to heavenly hummus-make every visit feel like a warm, delicious trip to Greece without leaving town.

12/28/2024 - Jackson T.
I absolutely adore Athena Greek Restaurant in Amityville - it's my go-to for delicious Greek food. I haven't found a better spot for Greek cuisine in the area, and I always leave satisfied with both the food and service.

05/18/2024 - Pearl W.
Awesome

02/11/2023 - MenuPix User
Best Lamb Gyro

08/30/2020 - Swan
The best Greek food I have ever had!

05/20/2016 - Kristen
I am not sure where to begin. The food has definitely suffered in recent years since the business changed owners. I still ordered as it's a restaurant in my hometown.

I had received a gift certificate. I had a balance of $5 I tried to use this on an order, but they refused because it had expired. As they could see I was using it as deductions were coming off the original purchase price. I have been a customer since I was a child!

The owner refused to accept it. As I asked why he got absolutely nasty with me with an arrogant attitude. I let him know he is losing my family as a loyal customer after years over $5. He told me the decision is mine.

This place used to be packed all the time. Now I go in you are lucky if two tables are full. Same name DIFFERENT RESTAURANT!

Think twice before going to this place!

I also have ordered a salad from here with undercooked chicken where my sister in-law and I got sick. When we called the owner same arrogant man refused to refund us or apologize !

09/30/2009 - Jeff
One of the best Greek's I've been to in 50+ years of eating. Never had a bad dish, mostly take away for us but lovely service in a family run 'tablecloth' restaurant. Old fashioned home cooked dishes, they take some time for prep-eat Euro style, what's the rush! Don't miss the skordalia.

Great homemade desserts also-the best chocolate cake(is that Greek?).