Reviews for Carmela's Pizza

06/18/2025 - Regina R.
After a night out at the Islander and Boston game, a few slices from Carmela's pizza were exactly what I needed to recover, with perfect sauce, sausage, and crust that kept me coming back. The friendly atmosphere, killer 80/90's freestyle music, fresh homemade food, and attentive service make every visit a memorable experience, whether dining in or ordering delivery.

09/17/2024 - Haley T.
Carmela's pizza came to my rescue one wild Friday night after a rowdy game. The slices were a lifesaver - sauce, sausage, crust, all perfection! The ambiance, the friendly service, and the killer 80/90's freestyle music make Carmela's a top-tier spot in my book. The food is always fresh, the sauce is unbeatable, and the personal pies are just the right size for a satisfying meal. You'll leave happy and full, making Carmela's your new favorite Italian joint in no time!

04/21/2024 - Robert U.
good

01/19/2010 - Joseph M
Best pizza on Long Island by Far! been eating here for over 15 years ...try their pesto pizza or old fashion sicilian grandma!