Reviews for Colleen's Pizza

04/18/2024 - MenuPix User

04/13/2024 - MenuPix User

03/04/2024 - MenuPix User

09/02/2020 - Terri Bradt
Wow! pleasantly surprised. Your pizza was delicious, we will definitely be getting it again. Good call Langford Superette.😀

12/04/2017 - Steve Garvey
SO.... Tops in Randolph was carrying Colleens Pizza.
They said they no longer have it. The manager said the TOPS in Ellicotville has it, so i went to there and
bought the 3 they had.
Damn ,no one local carries this best frozen pizza ever?..

03/04/2017 - ryan
BEST pizza bought a lot for a fundraiser everyone loved it

11/06/2016 - Steve Garvey Jamestown
Best frozen pizza ever!
Love this pizza. Our local Quality markets used to carry Colleen's but when Tops
Bought all of the Quality markets they stopped carrying it.
Is it available in Chautauqua county?

09/12/2015 - Terry
The best frozen pizza ever! I bake it for 18 minutes top rack on my own steel pan at 450°. Then slide it off the pan directly onto the top oven rack for around 5 minutes, to brown the bottom. Comes out perfect.

03/06/2015 - christine
I love this pizza but I have experienced no matter what I do the bottom does not brown before the top burns. My husband works in a bakery for 41 years and there is an issue with the yeast. This issue only happens once in awhile. It my be old pizza's.