Reviews for Frosty Treat

09/01/2025 - Leslie A.
This family-owned walk-up ice cream stand offers an incredible variety of creative sundaes, including vegan and no-sugar options, all at very reasonable prices. The staff is friendly and efficient, even when lines get long due to the high demand and impressive menu choices. Every visit brings new flavors and fun creations that make it hard to resist coming back again and again.

08/27/2024 - Team D.
Our first visit to this family-owned ice cream stand left us impressed by the wide selection of sundaes and the affordable prices. The staff is friendly and efficient, making the experience enjoyable despite the long lines.

06/05/2024 - Cynthia M.
amazing food and service.

07/17/2020 - Christine
Frosty Treat is very generous! Appreciate the variety... & creatively made ice cream creations. Thank you!

05/01/2020 - Jim Palmatier
Awesome

07/06/2010 - Unnamous
Me and my friend live in Silver Creek, and we go to Frosty Treat nearly everyday. It's amazing, and the service is very friendly, and not expensive. There are probably about 200 different sundae choices.

02/13/2010 - Shelley Boyles
I lived in Silver Creek, NY for 3 years. Several times a week my family would head to the Frosty Treat. It was always unbelievable how many people were waiting in line and waiting on the highway to get into the parking lot. More sundae choices than any human can imagine and for the money, a really great deal. Loved it! Wish I could go back just for the ice cream and to see the concrete penguin!