Reviews for Gary's Dairy & Deli

06/23/2025 - Courtney N.
Gary's sandwiches are amazing, fresh, affordable, and worth the wait every time I visit.

08/26/2024 - MenuPix User
So, I ordered a chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato and beacon on a sub. What I received was 1 frozen round chicken patty cut in half. 1 or 2 slices of beacon, 1 paper thin slice of tomato and 1 piece of lettuce. Hero sandwich was disgraceful to say the least. I know times are rough, but I paid $15! I will NEVER spend my hard-earned money for such a poor display of food that Gary's Deli had the nerve to sell me Ever Again! See the picture....

07/10/2024 - I L.
Delicious sandwiches at reasonable prices, though the bread selection can sometimes be limited. The sandwiches are always satisfying, especially with the hot pepper spread I love.

07/04/2024 - Alejandra M.
very good

09/01/2023 - Down the road
Good size sandwich for a reasonable price - unusual in Rhinebeck!

03/21/2023 - Ray
My favorite place in Rhinebeck to get a breakfast sandwich. Great staff.

06/13/2020 - MenuPix User
Best egg salad ever!!!!