Reviews for Paulie-Boy Hero Shop

05/03/2023 - MenuPix User
Always fresh and delicious

04/30/2023 - Robert W.
Best spot in town! The other reviews dont even sound like the same place… We have tried almost every sandwich on the menu and our kiddos have invented they’re own and we are always happy. Each sub can be a meal and a half— HEAVY and FULL of meat and cheese and whatever toppings you chose. My youngest eats one sandwich for 3 or 4 days. We think its a great deal for the quality and size. and we love that we can get a whole meal with sides, drinks and snacks. The desserts are definitely the cherry on top. The staff is usually very friendly but work hard and fast when there is a big line. This is our family favorite.

Gotta say to Leslie, the Italian sub is my wifes favorite and there is no blue cheese /relish sauce on it. It usually comes with mayo and Italian dressing. Maybe it got soggy and messed together since you were eating outside in august….

10/18/2022 - Gino
Great place, I go regularly, 3-4 times a week, have had at least 3/4s of their menu, and they’ll of course make you whatever you want, this is an old school New York City style sandwich shop, and they only use Boars Head, which is very important to me! Try a Kingston Beef! It’s unique to these guys and a very nice way to eat Roast Beef!

08/28/2022 - Leslie
I sent boyfriend to the new Paulie in Kingston Plaza to get a classic Italian Sub, I have been working on local yard sale for 2 days and just want a fresh Hero from somewhere close by, for his convenience.
The sub he returned with had EXCELLENT quality meat/cheese and bread - but, not only were the contents very skimpy, but they were slathered in some sort of mayo/blue cheese/relish dressing, that was awful and very messy. Not what I would have expected on an Italian - so I had to scrape all of that off.
Also, NOT A GOOD DEAL, since they only accept CASH, so he had to use THEIR ATM and pay an extra $3 service fee! SKIP THIS PLACE, even if Joe Beez is closed.....

08/25/2022 - MenuPix User
Just visited Paulie Boys hero shop for first time . I ordered a Ham/cheese/pepperoni,light on the cheese ,hero . 6 slices ham 8 slices pepperoni 3 slices yellow american $12 ! Although it was good thats much too much for such a small hero that. looked like a subway shop hero, nothing to it so i will not return there . Average price in this area is $9.50 and much much bigger hero .