Reviews for Goodfellas Pizzeria

04/29/2024 - Andrew W.
I am absolutely enamored with the pizza from this place! They serve a delightful selection of white and red sauce pizzas with generous toppings, always cooked to perfection. Despite the unassuming exterior and dining area, the pizzas here are simply divine, served fresh and hot in square or traditional pie shapes, accompanied by flavorful wings and fair prices.

02/14/2024 - MenuPix User

01/15/2024 - MenuPix User

01/09/2024 - MenuPix User

11/25/2023 - MenuPix User

05/21/2020 - MenuPix User
Always hot food, cooked to order. Delivery is quick and friendly. 😃

07/13/2015 - Gene
Used to be good but went downhill.wings undercooked. Pizza dough undercooked. Wouldn't order again.

09/26/2012 - Lori
Goodfellas pizza has the best tasting white pizza i have ever had. i recommend ordering a white pizza with sausage and broccoli. it is awesome. i have let my friends try it, and i always get an amazing response. kudos to Goodfellas. best white pizza EVER!!!

09/26/2012 - Renee
I order pizza from Goodfellas ALL the time. whether its just Pepperoni pizza or with extra toppings, its ALWAYS excellent. I usually have it delivered, and always it comes HOT. never received a cold or bad pizza from Goodfellas. I recommend Goodfellas to everyone! Best pizza delivered in Niagara Falls NY.