Reviews for Holy Cow

04/02/2025 - Freddie A.
During my visit to Hyde Park, I discovered an incredible ice cream shop. The soft serve is rich and creamy, making it a must-try for all ice cream lovers.

10/19/2024 - Serena H.
I stopped by this ice cream shop in Hyde Park while visiting from Manhattan, and let me tell you, their prices are unbeatable - just $1.50 for a kid's scoop! The coffee and holy cow flavors we tried were absolutely delicious, especially the homemade frozen yogurt. Despite the line on a hot day, it's worth the wait for such high-quality treats.

07/05/2024 - Jer R.
Good Food

06/27/2023 - MenuPix User
The best in the area. Going here for years and always take our out of town relatives! Best ice cream and hot fudge. Prices are great!

09/17/2022 - Bo
To Bill above

Animals don't belong in restaurants/ ice cream places etc. Emotional support? Get help Bill

06/05/2022 - Bill
I went in after waiting on line for 15 minutes. I had my little PomChi dog in my bag on my side - she goes with me everywhere. As I was getting ready to order the lady behind the counter exclaims "Sir - dogs are not allowed!" So I said fine and turned around and left - and I will never go back! I had my dog over a year now and she goes everywhere with me for emotional support and this was the 1st time I ever had a problem. She is always quiet and friendly in her pouch! And by the way - the window was not open for business which I would of gone to 1st. What a bad day trip for some ice cream !!

11/02/2021 - Diane Baker
We moved to Red Hook 18 years ago. Decided to take everyone for ice cream. A cue wrapped around the building with the iconic HOLY COW on the side. We couldn't believe how quickly, friendly and exciting it was. EVERY SINGLE ORDER was UNBELIEVABLY DELICIOUS 👍🏼
After several attempts to"assist"or"rescue" the lovely young girl helping us. We assumed she had made a mistake with the EXTRAORDINARILY LOW price! Let's just say there was a rather exuberant tip left (just in case).😉
PB has watched our children grow& thrive from birth. Now at 6'6"&6"1' we tend to wonder if it was the Holy Cow ice cream or her absolutely phenomenal staff.
You should never miss a trip , you won't be disappointed.
Thanks Holy Cow for many years of Birthday cakes, or Utters( just because)&millions of "specifically Robin"