Reviews for Madison's Pizza Cafe

08/13/2025 - Daisy V.
I've found this cozy neighborhood eatery to have some of the best NY-style pizza around, especially their grandma slices and perfectly chewy crust. The staff always greet me and my little one with warmth, making every visit feel like catching up with old friends. Beyond pizza, their diverse menu and generous portions keep me coming back again and again, whether dining in or ordering delivery.

03/20/2025 - Kamila P.
This cozy spot has a fantastic vibe, and the pizza is seriously delicious, so much so that I can't help but stop by a few times a week. The staff treats you like family, and they have a ton of tasty options beyond just pizza, like their amazing vodka sauce and summer salad. Plus, they always deliver with a smile, making it a go-to for me and my little one!

07/16/2024 - Nicki M.
Awesome food

06/10/2023 - Valley Lady!
Great food!
Nice place in dine!
Good delivery!

07/18/2020 - James K.
They have excellent food and a very attentive staff with smiles

05/08/2020 - MAC
My favorites are penne ala vodka, chicken parm. & pizza! Try it!

03/04/2020 - Ann
Always great!!!!

01/31/2015 - Dick
This pizza is awful. Only a drunk would buy this crap to avoid driving to Poughkeepsie. Delivery was one hour although only 2.5 miles. Pizza was cheap cheese, over salted crap. Worst I have ever had in this area. Ate two pieces and wanted to puke.

03/28/2014 - Maggie
The girl that finally found it in her to tear herself away from chatting with her friends, took my order then disappeared. If you have a question everyone keeps there head down so you wont bother them. AND to boot the pizza was terrible- like its been sitting out for days, couldn't possible chew it!!

07/16/2010 - Suzanne
I love them! Not only do they deliver but they are the best Pizza place around! Try their Chicken and Broccoli Alfredo Pizza! My kids favorite!

05/23/2010 - Wayne Sepe
The food is outstanding. Try the linguine with red clam sauce, its to die for! Everything i have ever had has always been excellent.