Reviews for Mama Gina's Pizzeria

03/19/2024 - MenuPix User

12/07/2023 - MenuPix User

04/17/2022 - TBD
The wood fired pizza cook is a total sad excuse of a man. He wanted to yell at a young waitress like he was running a kitchen for Gordon Ramsey. Food was average for a small town, but the cooks are terrible.

03/27/2021 - MenuPix User
Ordered a large garlic pizza with tomato.... OMG.... So freaking good, a the crust was homemade!!! Will order this again!

04/26/2014 - none
we just moved to fulton and was looking for a nice place for my husbands birthday, this was the closest and a nice looking place to go. He order Chicken parm... the chicken looked like a serving for a child and the pasta wasnt cooked all the way, our daughter ordered onion soup, there was more cheese in it then soup. also the calzones, looked like a large keiser roll sandwich... horrible. chicken wings were way over cooked. prices were way high for the amount of food you get... the waitstaff acted like WE were in the wrong... needless to say, she didnt get much of a tip... never going there again... this place really sucks... doesnt look like they get much in the line of customers during the day or night time... sad.. could be a great place.. but NOT

04/26/2014 - JUST A SALAD
I ORDERED A GRILLED CHICKEN SALAD. CHICKEN WAS COLD WHEN IT CAME OUT. COMPLAINED TO THE WAITRESS, AND THE COOK JUST HEATED IT IN THE MICROWAVE. UNPROFESSIONAL TO ME. COOK A NEW ONE FOR YOUR CUSTOMERS! NOT A GOOD PLACE TO EAT.

06/22/2013 - Beth Caprin/Nixdorf
We ordered pizza and wings last night(wings crispy). Called today to complain, wings not crispy and pizza was burned on the bottom. Manager said he could do nothing today, we should have called last night. He said that was company policy. We will never order anything from Mama Gina's again!

04/28/2012 - maria adams
i used to order from this business alot i had left town and came back to find it a shame. I ordered a large extra cheese pizza with pepperoni and i got there no extra cheese they put more cheese on and reheated it. then the top looked burned. I am so upset this used to be the best pizza in town. i did not mind paying there high prices because they were good their fettuccini alfredo with chicken was to die for but now this pizza is like supermarket pizza. if i am paying 17.00 a pizza i want that quality now it looks like supermarket puizza is even better then this and to top it off i did take pizza home and it tasted too salty and not how they used to make it please save yourself money go to your local pricechopper and get better quality for just 8.00