Reviews for Mamma Mia Restaurant

03/21/2015 - GKB
Orderd a pie with 1/2 having an additional topping. It was picked up on time and brought straight home, less than a 5 minute drive. When the pie arrived at the house, the table was set, no delay getting it plated and it was cold! Not hot, not warm, it was almost ice cold. The cheese was congealed and waxy looking. It appeared the pie was one they had made earlier and had sitting at the ready (cold), threw some extra cheese on the half with the extra topping so it would stick and they may have thrown it in the oven for a quick melt.

Now, being a NYC guy, I know the best pies taste great cold, so we ate it. It wasn't terrible. The crust was crispy at the and to make for a nice fold, but after the fold, the rest of the crust was like a wet paper towel. Soggy and floppy! Again, the taste wasn't terrible, so I will try it again. If they make it fresh on the spot, I think it will be some of the best pie in the area. If they pull that crap again, I'm walklin without paying after telling them why!

Another hinest review will follow after my second visit!