Reviews for Matthew's Seafood House

5 stars |
![]() |
|
2 votes - | 14% |
4 stars |
![]() |
|
4 votes - | 29% |
3 stars |
![]() |
|
6 votes - | 43% |
2 stars |
![]() |
|
1 votes - | 7% |
1 star |
![]() |
|
1 votes - | 7% |
Latest MenuPix Reviews
07/02/2025 - Sandy E.
During my visit to Fire Island, I enjoyed several meals at Matthew's Seafood House, where the fresh steamers stood out as the best I had, accompanied by friendly service and a breezy patio right on the dock. The menu offered a variety of delicious options like lobster, shrimp parm, and Mediterranean halibut, complemented by great drinks and live music, making it an ideal spot for both casual dinners and special celebrations.
08/25/2017 - Steve
Horrible, rude staff! Waiter rude and was not available for basic things we needed like extra napkins, kids refills. Will never go back!