Reviews for Matthew's Seafood House

review_stars 
3.4 stars - Based on 14 votes
View Menu Go Back
5 stars review_stars
2 votes - 14%
4 stars review_stars
4 votes - 29%
3 stars review_stars
6 votes - 43%
2 stars review_stars
1 votes - 7%
1 star review_stars
1 votes - 7%
Write a Review
star1 star2 star3 star4 star5


Latest MenuPix Reviews

review_stars 07/02/2025 - Sandy E.
During my visit to Fire Island, I enjoyed several meals at Matthew's Seafood House, where the fresh steamers stood out as the best I had, accompanied by friendly service and a breezy patio right on the dock. The menu offered a variety of delicious options like lobster, shrimp parm, and Mediterranean halibut, complemented by great drinks and live music, making it an ideal spot for both casual dinners and special celebrations.

review_stars 08/25/2017 - Steve
Horrible, rude staff! Waiter rude and was not available for basic things we needed like extra napkins, kids refills. Will never go back!


Long Island Restaurant Guide: See Menus, Ratings and Reviews for Restaurants in Long Island and New York
United States Restaurant Guide:
AK | AL | AR | AZ | CA | CT | CO | DE | FL | GA | HI | ID | IL | IN | IA | KS | KY | LA | MD | ME | MA | MI | MN | MS | MO | MT | NC | ND | NE | NV | NH | NJ | NM | NY | OH | OK | OR | PA | RI | SC | SD | TN | TX | UT | VT | VA | WA | WV | WI | WY
Canadian Major Cities and Provinces:
Alberta | British Columbia | Manitoba | New Brunswick | Newfoundland | Nova Scotia | Ontario | Prince Edward Island | Quebec | Saskatchewan | Yukon | Calgary | Edmonton | Montreal | Ottawa | Regina | Saskatoon | Toronto | Vancouver | Victoria | Winnipeg |
Most Popular US City Guides:
Albuquerque | Amherst | Atlanta | Austin | Baltimore | Boston | Boulder | Brooklyn | Burlington | Cape Cod | Charlotte | Charleston | Chicago | Cincinnati | Cleveland | Columbus | Dallas / Fort Worth | Denver | Detroit | El Paso | Flagstaff | Fort Lauderdale | Fresno | Gulf Coast | Hartford | Hoboken | Honolulu | Houston | Indianapolis | Jackson | Jacksonville | Jersey City | Kansas City | Knoxville | Las Vegas | Long Island | Los Angeles | Louisville | Lowell | Madison | Memphis | Miami | Milwaukee | Minneapolis | Myrtle Beach | Nashua | Nashville | New Orleans | New York City | Oakland | Oklahoma City | Omaha | Orange County | Orlando | Philadelphia | Phoenix | Pittsburgh | Portland | Providence | Raleigh | Reno | Richmond | Riverside | Sacramento | Saint Louis | Salem | Salt Lake City | San Antonio | San Diego | San Francisco | San Jose | Santa Barbara | Santa Fe | Seattle | St. Paul | Tampa | Tucson | Tulsa | Twin Cities | Virginia Beach | Washington, DC | Wilmington | Winston-Salem
revised