Reviews for Michael T's Restaurant

06/20/2025 - Amor T.
Michael T's delivers an exceptional culinary experience with tender, flavorful dishes like Chicken Ann Marie topped with vibrant Utica greens and a tomato sauce that sings with authenticity. The attentive, warm service complements generous portions of Italian classics, creating a welcoming atmosphere that keeps me coming back whenever I'm in the area.

08/05/2024 - Fritz W.
We celebrated our wedding rehearsal dinner at this wonderful venue the night before our special day. The owner and bartender provided outstanding service, and the food was absolutely delicious, leaving a lasting impression on our guests. The private room reserved for our party added a special touch to the evening, and we would definitely recommend this venue for any event hosting needs. Our experience exceeded our expectations, and we are grateful for the attentive service and incredible dining experience.

01/18/2011 - Susan
We've frequented Michael T's at least 15 times in the last 3 years. Each visit was a little worse than the one before. On our last visit the food was worse than poor, the pasta and sauce tasted like Chef Boyaredee. The nightly special- prime rib was all fat, when it was sent back to the kitchen, the chef/owner blamed us. He said that one end of the roast was fatter than the other,and if you order it that's the chance you take???? Go somewhere else, anywhere else, stay away from this poor excuse for a restaurant!!!

11/19/2010 - just me
This visit was extremely disappointing!! The food was NOT at all what it appeared to be. There was no taste or flavor since most everything seemed to have a "rinsed off" water-soaked taste. AGHH the thought/memory is chilling. It was a waste of time and money for us. We went for the advertised luncb buffet. Families who had come after us, left long before us. Apparently, we were not the only ones disappointed. Horrible, but worse when you have to pay and leave a tip. Not happy about that at all. The riggie sauce was okay, but no meat. The greens were watery, NO FLAVOR AT ALL. Likewise, the gross PORK bracciole--BLAH. The potatoes were nice and crisp. The meatballs were ALSO tasteless and WATERY. WHAT'S WITH THE WATER-SOAKED, RINSED OFF TASTE. Not good.