Reviews for Mt Sinai Heritage Diner

04/15/2024 - MenuPix User

12/20/2023 - MenuPix User

11/19/2023 - MenuPix User

08/08/2009 - Best Kept Secret on Long Islad
The new menu truly separates them from all diners on LI. This is a menu you would find at one of those trendy village eateries in the city. They have a great sandwich i always order called the fresh apple provolone grilled chicken avocado on french baguette bread. you must check them out.

06/21/2009 - George Hapkins
I was there today and the placed was jammed packed. I can't say i liked the 20 min wait but it was well worth it. The place and menu was just remodeled. Beautiful granite tables everywhere and nice tv's playing the US Open. The menu was simply Amazing. New flavors and breads. This is not your typical diner. They have like 10 types of pancakes and sandwiches. Try the Grilled banana walnut buttermilk pancakes it was insane. I think it was like $7!! I don't know how they stay in business with these prices and such an upscale atmosphere, but i'm glad to have them in the neighborhood.

06/16/2009 - Larry
I never heard to much about this diner because I don't think to many people know about it but it was pretty crowded when we went to eat dinner and I thought the food was really good. I heard a few people at the other tables say the food was really good too. I guess it depends on when you go in but we were very surprised and happy with our dinner and it was busy in there.

06/11/2009 - dennis
worst philly cheesesteak ever. Two thick fatty slices of "roast beef" with melted american chese on top. Not even close.
They need a new chef.

06/10/2009 - Jan lewis
The food is over priced and inferior. Actually bad food. The service is slow.
No wonder is was empty, people know bad food & service when they see it.