Reviews for Mustachio's Pizzeria

08/11/2025 - I T.
Buffalo has no shortage of great pizza, but Mustachio's somehow rises above the delicious chaos with its garlicky, perfectly doughy crust and inventive pies like the spaghetti and chicken parmesan combo that surprisingly won me over. The bright yellow boxes, friendly staff, and tasty sides like their famous berry salad and apple logs make every visit feel like a treat, even if the dining area is tiny-definitely a must-try for anyone craving that Buffalo-style slice!

06/24/2024 - Queen A.
good food good service

04/25/2024 - Scott D.
Mustachio's in Buffalo stands out among the abundance of delicious pizza options in the city. I have fond memories of their Parkside location, where we enjoyed our meal at the counter in a cozy setting perfect for pickup or delivery. Their spaghetti and chicken parmesan pizza was a surprising but delightful choice, with a slightly doughy base and a well-seasoned, garlicky crust that perfectly complemented the toppings. The fresh fruit salad and tasty dessert options added to the overall enjoyable dining experience, making Mustachio's a top choice for Buffalo-style pizza lovers like myself.