Reviews for New York Pizzeria

09/30/2024 - Kaitlyn P.
The pizzeria used to be pretty mediocre. The pizza was always lacking in flavor and too thin, but now that there are new owners and staff, it's like a whole new spot. The food is really tasty and the prices are fair, plus the staff are super friendly. It's become my go-to pizza joint in town!

01/04/2014 - Karen
I bought two (sheet) pizzas that had stale crusts!!!!!
The vegetables toppings were still raw!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The cheese was not melted,there was not enough sauce,everything was falling off the top and was cold!!!!!!!!!! Then I called the owner of the place to complain so he said that he would trade the two sheet pizzas for three large pizzas because he was done for the night. This was at 6:30 pm on a Saturday!!!!!!!! And then I give a piece to my dog and he just turned up his nose to it!!!! And he loves pizza!!!! So this shows that not even a dog would eat this piece of crap!!!! So why do they think that a human would? They need to go back to cooking school if they think this pizza of their is edible!!! I will never go back to this Pizzeria ever again!!!! I will spend the gas money to go to Lisle's Pizzeria the next time I want pizza that is edible!!!