Reviews for New York Pizzeria

09/22/2024 - Andrew G.
The pizza here is consistently delicious, with a perfect balance of crust, sauce, and toppings. The staff is friendly and the service is fast, making for a pleasant dining experience. I appreciate the authenticity of the New York-style slices and the variety of options available.

05/06/2024 - Trip M.
Great food at a great price

04/29/2022 - MenuPix User
The pizza is Excellent!!

10/17/2020 - Elvis
Awesome Pizza friendly staff did I mention awesome pizza

07/22/2020 - Bob K.
I live in Ithaca where there are several good pizzerias. Nonetheless, I frequently drive to Trumansburg to order pizza from the New York Pizzeria there since the quality of their pizza is second-to-none. I strongly recommend New York Pizzeria in Trumansburg for truly exceptional pizza, as well as any of their other items.

06/04/2020 - MenuPix User
We've always loved the pizza In T -burg and were so happy you're open again.
The crust is thin and light and the toppings are fresh. Yum!

08/19/2018 - Holly S.
Best local pizza restaurant. Calzones are amazing as well.

11/08/2017 - Charlie
Absolutely the best pizza you'll ever get in these parts!

01/02/2016 - Mari
Are you people ever open? If so Hope can you stay in business not answering your phone..???