Reviews for New York Pizzeria

06/26/2025 - James I.
The pizza here truly captures the authentic New York flavor, with fresh ingredients and a crust that's just right, making every bite memorable. The owners and staff treat everyone like family, creating a warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes you want to come back again and again. From the friendly conversations to the delicious homemade dishes, this restaurant brings a special charm to the community that's hard to find anywhere else.

05/13/2024 - Ann H.
great food

05/04/2024 - Maddie E.
Frank's Pizzeria in New Berlin serves the best Italian food with fantastic service and a welcoming atmosphere.

08/09/2023 - MenuPix User
Great food! Staff is awesome! Thank the guy that makes heros!!!

09/05/2021 - Debra Hinman
We were up visiting from Florida to see family. We stopped in to get pizza one day. The pizza is absolutely amazing!! We loved it!! The pizza was great and the staff was friendly!! Anything we have had since doesn't even compare. If we get up that again, we would love to stop in. We haven't found anything that great in Florida!

12/14/2018 - Marianna
The best pizza and Italian food.
The decor is superb and the owner such a sweetheart, it really feels home (Italy).
I love the food just the right good old italian flavor and spice.
I just wish was in Norwich.