Reviews for Nick & Toni's

06/26/2025 - Agustin R.
The food at this restaurant is consistently excellent, with dishes like focaccia, zucchini chips, grilled swordfish, NY steak, and house-made ricotta cavatelli standing out, complemented by impeccable service from attentive staff such as Luis and Kirsten. Despite being busy, seating was quick and the atmosphere enjoyable, making it a reliable choice for dining in East Hampton with a great wine selection and both indoor and outdoor seating options.

12/07/2024 - Alexandra T.
I had an incredible dining experience at Nick & Toni's, with a variety of delicious dishes that left me wanting to return. The service was exceptional and the atmosphere was lively, making it a must-visit in East Hampton.

05/03/2024 - Tracey O.
Great food!

09/14/2013 - Donny C.
This place is a joke. They hold the best tables "in waiting" for any walk in celebrity clientele, while the other patrons are delegated to the bar, or the dark and dingy back rooms that are like a cheap diner. The hostess and staff are nasty and arrogant, and the menu is limited and lifeless. This should be a negative starred restaurant. Join the boycott, forget stargazing (apart from those in the sky and on TV/movies) and let Nick & Toni's see how well they do fiscally with only occasional celebrity patrons. Have some respect for yourself and avoid this place like the plague. It will provide nothing but a disgustingly unpalatable experience that you won't easily forget.