Reviews for Oakley's Place

04/15/2025 - Lea M.
Every time I'm in Margaretville, I make a point to eat at Oakley's because their pizza absolutely blows away the local pizzerias back in Brooklyn. The wood-fired flavor is incredible, and even their burgers are surprisingly fantastic; I can't wait to go back for more!

09/09/2024 - Clyde D.
Every time I visit Margaretville, I make sure to grab a meal at Oakley's. The pizza there rivals some of the best pizzerias in my Brooklyn neighborhood. The wood-fired oven truly elevates the flavors, creating a crispy crust that is unmatched. If you find yourself nearby, it's definitely worth stopping by for a memorable dining experience.

06/04/2024 - Ariane V.
The food was great

10/07/2016 - Al Bradbury
Never been a better stop, Pizza, Burger Fries Just really good super clean stuff.

07/25/2016 - Connie
Tried this place 3x....it is "underwhelming" at best but the last trip was the worst,"steak" night...12.95 for a piece of "steak" that was 1/8" touted to come with a baked potato, came with 1/2 of a boiled potato and salad on the same plate that consisted of a few sprigs of lettuce. Was supposed to have garlic knots with the meal but lo and behold they were out of them @ 5:30 p.m. Don't waste your money. They get away with this shoddy food because quite frankly there are few places to eat in the area.

01/02/2013 - Karen
The BEST Pizza in the Catskills . Friendly and very accommodating -