Reviews for The Old Library Restaurant

08/29/2024 - Jean V.
The food and service were exceptional, with the lobster being served piping hot, a rare treat for seafood dishes. The filet was cooked to perfection, tender and succulent, like slicing through butter. The atmosphere was lovely, making for a memorable dining experience that I look forward to repeating.

02/17/2021 - Pamela Shafer
Looked at the menu last week, saw that Pasta Louis was still available on their menu. Came up to visit from SC, wanted to take some back home. The man who answered the phone said it was not available this week, told him I saw it last week on their webpage so I thought it was available all the time, he stated that it wasn't..very rudely I might add. Joe Marra...you are greatly missed!! You would have gone out of your way to make sure I had some to take back with me! Guess my days of going to this restaurant when I'm in town is over. Miss the Marra family!!

08/13/2020 - 8/13/20 Older person
Menu tries to be extremely 5 star and misses by many miles. If have any dietary problems, do not eat here. Menu has too fancy descriptions which do not aptly let you know what exactly you will be eating! Food prices are very high! Drink prices are ridiculous!!! 1 mixed drink, vodka tonic with GreyGoose Vodka $10.00, 2 Bud Lights $11.00 Service was good! Deco is very nice!