Reviews for Old Street Pub

08/10/2025 - Karan R.
The food at Old Street Pub in Smithtown is consistently well-prepared and flavorful, with standout items like the steak sandwich, burgers, and homestyle dishes that offer good value and generous portions. The service is generally attentive and timely, the atmosphere has an old-world charm suitable for casual dining, and while parking can be limited on busy nights, the overall experience makes returning worthwhile.

02/16/2025 - Lindsay N.
The service was prompt and friendly, and the atmosphere exuded a cozy, old-world charm that made our visit enjoyable. I savored the lean corned beef with crispy French fries, while my wife relished her Danish burger topped with blue cheese and bacon; we ended our meal with a delicious carrot cake that perfectly capped off the evening.

06/16/2024 - Jason B.
The food is good

02/25/2021 - MenuPix User
Great bar food including the baked clams!