Reviews for O'Mally's

12/19/2021 - MenuPix User
Arrived before 6p, 4 of us at the table. 3 ordered steaks & they arrived over cooked. They had advised there’s be Prime rib/end cut & none to be had, they ran out. The buns on my sliders looked stale & there was no dessert available except, an ice cream dish with raspberry sauce. No cakes, cheesecakes etc., to be had at that time (7p?) & I was hoping to gift my husband cake for his birthday! Waitress blamed it on the lunch crowd, everyone came in with gift cards that day? Oh, well & the toilet top in one of bathroom stalls was broken off? We were not happy but, we were hungry, ate & left. Not sure we’ll return, we’ve been there before but, feel something was off on this visit.

04/22/2017 - Rini
Fantastic Burgers....i almost always order one with onion rings. They are so tasty, big, juicy...everything a burger should be. A pleasant surprise to me as well was the octopus. It is, hands down, the best octopus I have ever eaten.....if they have it when you are there, don't even hesitate...just order it before it's gone! Always stuffed when I leave O'Mallys!!!

02/14/2017 - Margie & Rick Knowlden
Fantastic quinine! After many visits, the food is always delicious. Whether its steak or fish or even a hamburger the chef is always consistent with generous servings of mouth watering dishes at reasonable prices. Family friendly and great for parties. A frequented local favorite and a must when visiting the North Fork!

10/24/2015 - Ron Zoni
This place is absolutely awesome. Food is great, prices are great, the staff is great. Steve, Joe, Greg & Jenni are the best! I can't believe people are giving negative reviews because an old dirty rug & moose heads have been replaced?! This place has the BEST burgers on the North Fork, the FRESHEST sea food & the most delicious deserts! See for yourself! This place is by far the BEST!

02/14/2015 - Ed Burke
I LOVED, PAST TENSE, eating at O'Malley's in Southold. NEW OWNERS have redone everything, but the staple of my past visits was a Chili Cheeseburger I loved, last night I ordered it amidst the smell of the new paint AND NOW GONE DATED ATMOSPHERE I RATHER ENJOYED.

The cheeseburger was heavier, but though I ordered it 'medium' and it was cooked that way, the meat was dry,and hard to bite into. The once thick meaty tasty chili was now a watery gravy that soaked half the bun, the other half of the bun was Ice Cold, as in they must store the bred in an unheated closet with outside vent.

A missing item was manhattan clam chowder, instead there was a 'muscle bisque' ? Never heard of that before. Didn't order any soup. The list of 'specials' was all FISH, at a place known for burgers.

Oh, and the prices have all gone UP !

So if you love O'Malley's it has the sign still there but little else, and the CC receipts had "Toms NOFO" on it, not O'Malley's

12/04/2010 - Bob Buscavage
Last night on our way back from the Orient Point ferry, my wife & I finally stopped for dinner at O'Mally's, a restaurant we have always wanted to visit. Holiday music was playing and we were greeted by Phil, the owner who made us feel right at home as soon as we entered. My wife also casually mentioned that it was my husband's birthday (Bob) We both enjoyed fabulous burgers with all the trimmings as well as wonderful service from Carol. I was then surprised by the whole restaurant serenading me with Happy Birthday followed by a candle & cake and then a picture. It will be one of the most memorable birthdays ever...THANK YOU, PHIL...WE cant wait to return for an encore of fine dining.