Reviews for Otto's Delicatessen

07/12/2025 - Andrew T.
I swung by Otto's on my way to the library because I needed a quick bite after work, and honestly, the chicken cutlet hero blew me away-fresh, perfectly stacked, and made just how I like it. The staff there are super friendly and laid-back, making the whole experience feel welcoming, plus the deli is clean and everything is made-to-order with quality ingredients like Boar's Head meats. I'm definitely coming back to try the paninis and homemade salads, and if you're around the South Shore, this deli's got some of the best sandwiches and sides you'll find.

03/08/2025 - Garrett L.
On my way to the Wantagh library, I found myself in need of a quick bite after work and decided to give a nearby deli a shot. The atmosphere was welcoming, the staff down-to-earth and polite, and the chicken cutlet hero exceeded my expectations, making me eager to return for more of their enticing menu.