Reviews for Papa Nick's Pizza

5 stars |
![]() |
|
8 votes - | 30% |
4 stars |
![]() |
|
17 votes - | 63% |
3 stars |
![]() |
|
2 votes - | 7% |
2 stars |
![]() |
|
0 votes - | 0% |
1 star |
![]() |
|
0 votes - | 0% |
Latest MenuPix Reviews
07/08/2025 - Ricki A.
The pizza here is truly exceptional, especially the Nonna pie and the sesame crust variety, both bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection. The staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming, making every visit enjoyable, and their specials like the garlic knots and moms night off deal are definitely worth trying.
02/21/2025 - June D.
I discovered a fantastic pizza spot that serves the best pizza on Long Island, run by wonderful people who truly care about their customers. The Nonna pie is a standout, with a perfect balance of crunchy and soft dough, delicious sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. Every visit offers a memorable experience, with friendly staff, a great selection of flavors, and a commitment to supporting the local community.
06/16/2023 - drbob
Always polite always on time and always delicious