Reviews for Five Islands Lobster Co

08/13/2025 - Reese O.
The lobster roll was really good, with just the right amount of mayo on a warm bun, though the haddock chowder was a bit light on fish and potatoes. The whole vibe is super casual and classic Maine, with picnic tables right on the harbor, making it perfect for a relaxed meal while watching fishing boats and enjoying the fresh sea air. Prices are reasonable, the fried clams and onion rings are solid, and the dog-friendly outdoor seating with stunning views makes it a great spot to hang out and savor some fresh seafood.

08/04/2024 - Tiff D.
The lobster roll and haddock chowder we tried had their own unique qualities - the lobster roll was excellent, while the chowder lacked a bit in terms of fish and potatoes. The pricing was reasonable, especially for the lobsters, and the selection allowed for a traditional lobster pound experience. The coleslaw added a homemade touch to the meal and the picturesque view from the lobster pound was truly stunning.