Reviews for Pizza Shack I

06/21/2025 - Terry B.
The experience ordering was a bit off-putting, as the person on the phone seemed reluctant to take the order and failed to mention the cash-only policy, which was only discovered upon arrival. The pizza itself was disappointing, with a thick crust, sparse toppings, and an overall flat appearance that suggested old dough might have been used. In contrast, a nearby establishment offers a more satisfying pizza with generous toppings and a better overall flavor, making it a preferable choice for those seeking quality and value.

09/05/2024 - Jan G.
I phoned in my order and the guy on the other end sounded like I was bothering him by calling it in! We got a big pizza, light sauce, half pepperoni, half plain cheese. When we arrived, there was a sign saying 'Cash Only'. I wondered why the guy taking my order didn't mention it on the phone. Luckily, they had an ATM in the store, but I couldn't help but think they might be getting a cut of the ATM fee.